Steel decarbonisation debates usually turn on technology: hydrogen, direct reduction, electric arc furnaces, renewable power. A report launched by the UNFCCC Technology Executive Committee (TEC) at COP31 on 12 November shifts the emphasis to something less photogenic but arguably more binding — the absence of a common way to measure and certify what counts as low- or near-zero-emission steel.
The TEC analysis, produced with UNIDO and titled Analysis of Standards and Labels for Low and Near Zero Emission Production and Products, maps regulatory and voluntary standards, carbon-intensity thresholds and certification mechanisms across steel, cement and low-emission hydrogen. Its central observation, as reported by SteelOrbis, is that divergent emissions accounting, system boundaries, verification requirements and thresholds limit international comparability — and that certified low- or near-zero-emission production remains below 1% of global output across all three product groups.
A note on sourcing: the TEC report itself is an official UNFCCC document, but its full text was not directly accessible for this analysis. The figures below are as reported by SteelOrbis summarising the report, and are treated as indicative rather than verified against the primary PDF.
The numbers that frame the problem
The report's emissions data are not novel individually, but the way they are juxtaposed exposes the comparability gap.
| Metric | Value (as reported) |
|---|---|
| Steel share of global emissions | ~7% |
| BF-BOF share of global output / intensity | ~71% / ~2.3 t CO₂ per t steel |
| EAF share of output | ~29% (scrap-based average ~0.69 t CO₂/t crude steel, 2024) |
| ResponsibleSteel certification range cited | ~1.1–1.8 t CO₂/t crude steel (EAF-based ~0.6–1.0 t) |
| EU ETS free-allocation benchmark | ~1.328 t CO₂/t hot-rolled steel |
| First Movers Coalition near-zero threshold | ≤0.4 t CO₂/t, cradle-to-gate |
| Certified low-/near-zero output | <1% of global output (steel, cement, H₂) |
The arithmetic is stark. Average scrap-based EAF steel at ~0.69 t CO₂/t sits roughly 1.7 times above the 0.4 t near-zero ceiling; conventional BF-BOF at ~2.3 t is nearly six times above it. Even the most common "green" production route in use today does not clear the most demanding procurement threshold — which explains why certified volumes remain marginal despite years of announcements.
The real issue is not the numbers but the per-tonne basis
A common misreading is that these thresholds can be lined up on a single scale and ranked. They cannot, and this is precisely what the TEC report is flagging.
- The EU ETS benchmark (~1.328 t) is a free-allocation reference for hot-rolled product, set within a specific allocation methodology and scope. It is a policy instrument, not a product label.
- The First Movers Coalition threshold (≤0.4 t) is a cradle-to-gate procurement definition, per tonne of crude steel.
- ResponsibleSteel certification depends on production route and assessment boundary, with a range spanning roughly 1.1–1.8 t.
Comparing a per-tonne-hot-rolled allocation benchmark with a per-tonne-crude cradle-to-gate ceiling is, strictly, an apples-to-oranges exercise. That mismatch is the point: buyers, exporters and regulators are routinely forced to make exactly that comparison in procurement and border-adjustment contexts.
There is also a simplification worth correcting. The 0.4 t figure is often presented as a flat ceiling, but the underlying methodologies (ResponsibleSteel's Level 4, the IEA's near-zero definition and the FMC commitment) generally use a scrap-variable sliding scale, declining from ~0.40 t CO₂e/t at zero scrap to ~0.05 t at 100% scrap. The flat 0.4 t presentation in trade coverage understates how much the definition depends on scrap input — and therefore how differently a scrap-rich producer and an ore-based producer will fare under nominally the same standard. (These sliding-scale details come from ResponsibleSteel, IEA and Agora Industry material rather than direct verification of the TEC text; they should be confirmed against the final UNFCCC document.)
Why this matters commercially, not just technically
The fragmentation is not an abstract governance complaint. It has three concrete consequences for steel trade.
1. Border measures need a defensible metric. The EU's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism requires importers to declare embedded emissions. If the underlying accounting rules and thresholds are not interoperable across jurisdictions, CBAM compliance becomes a documentation burden that disadvantages exporters with genuinely lower-carbon routes but non-aligned certification.
2. Route structure becomes a trade asset. The report singles out Turkey, where EAF accounts for roughly 70–75% of steelmaking capacity. That gives Turkish producers a structurally lower average embodied-emissions profile than BF-dominated industries. Turkey's first Climate Law took effect in July 2025, providing the legal basis for a national ETS; a draft regulation published 22 July 2025 proposed an intensity-based cap, benchmark-guided free allocation and coverage of installations emitting at least 50,000 t CO₂e annually. The combination — EAF-heavy capacity plus a domestic carbon price aligned with EU requirements — could position Turkish steel favourably under CBAM-related procurement. Whether it does depends on whether its MRV and certification are recognised.
3. Green procurement is the demand lever. The report points to aggregated purchasing commitments — FMC members such as Ford and Volvo targeting steel below 0.4 t CO₂/t by 2030 — as the main mechanism to create demand for certified near-zero product. But those commitments are only usable if suppliers can prove compliance under a recognised scheme.
The projects exist; the market architecture does not
The report catalogues industrial projects that show the technology is no longer the binding constraint:
| Project | Location | Approach | Reported emissions impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Baosteel Zhanjiang | China | H₂-DRI + scrap + EAF + low-carbon rolling (1 Mt/y line connected Dec 2025) | 50–80% reduction vs BF-BOF; up to 3.14 Mt CO₂/y avoided |
| HYBRIT | Sweden | Renewable hydrogen replaces coking coal in reduction | 90–95% reduction potential |
| Stegra | Sweden | H₂-DRI + EAF, renewable power | 5 Mt/y design capacity by 2030 |
| SALCOS | Germany | H₂-DRI + EAF replacing blast furnaces | ~2.3 → ~0.4 t CO₂/t |
This is a meaningful shift in the report's framing. The barriers it identifies are high capex, insufficient hydrogen and renewable electricity infrastructure, financing difficulty and — critically — limited demand for certified products. The last of these is a standards problem dressed as a market problem.
The recommendation: interoperability over harmonisation
The TEC's proposed remedy avoids the trap of demanding a single global threshold. It recommends multi-tier international reference standards that account for differences in national industrial development and technological readiness, rather than uniform global thresholds. It also calls for stronger digital MRV, interoperability of national certification frameworks, and expanded financial support through concessional finance, tax incentives and carbon contracts for difference.
This aligns with independent analysis. Agora Industry's November 2026 study Made to measure: tailoring steel standards to policy goals reaches a similar conclusion — recommending phased scope expansion and scrap-differentiated thresholds, and framing the goal explicitly as "interoperability" rather than harmonisation. Its modelling found that shifting scrap share from 20% to 70% can more than halve the cost gap between hydrogen-DRI and conventional routes in several major economies.
That convergence is significant: the UNFCCC process and independent analysts are arriving at the same design principle from different directions. The practical implication is that a multi-tier, scrap-sensitive architecture is more likely to be adopted than a single number — and producers should expect standards to converge on structure while remaining differentiated on thresholds.
What to watch
- Whether the final TEC text (DOC TEC/2026/32/16 and successors) formalises the multi-tier recommendation or softens it under political pressure for a single benchmark.
- Whether Turkey's ETS design and MRV are recognised as interoperable with EU frameworks ahead of full CBAM implementation.
- Whether FMC-style purchasing commitments are honoured at scale — the <1% certified share will not move without them.
- Whether the sliding-scale approach (0.40 → 0.05 t by scrap share) becomes the de facto reference, which would materially change how ore-based and scrap-based producers are compared.
For steelmakers, the operational takeaway is that carbon intensity alone will not determine market access. Certifiability — the ability to prove a given intensity under a recognised, interoperable methodology — is becoming a parallel competitive requirement. Companies that build MRV capability and align with the emerging multi-tier structure early will be better positioned than those waiting for a single harmonised standard that may never arrive.
Reported figures are attributed to the SteelOrbis summary of the UNFCCC TEC report. Calculations and the sliding-scale correction draw on ResponsibleSteel, IEA and Agora Industry material; the primary TEC text should be consulted for definitive thresholds.
Source & methodology +
MetalMate separates original-source evidence from summary and analysis. Verify the original source before procurement, legal or engineering decisions.
- Article status
- Published · Version 1
- Source date
- 12 November 2026
- MetalMate publication
- 13 November 2026
- Verification
- Automated evidence checks; not human reviewed
