On 11 November 2026, Assofermet — the Italian association covering steel, scrap and metals trading, distribution and processing — sent a letter to Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, with copies to DG TAXUD, DG CLIMA and the Italian government, asking that the CBAM de minimis threshold be raised tenfold, from 50 to 500 tonnes per importer per year. The trigger is the proposed extension of CBAM to downstream steel and aluminium products; the argument is administrative proportionality for SMEs.
The substantive case is stronger than the timing suggests, and the arithmetic behind it is more awkward than the association's framing admits. The threshold that currently exists was not chosen to protect small importers: it was chosen to protect a 99% emissions-coverage target. Any debate about raising it is, at root, a debate about whether that target should survive the move into finished goods.
What is actually being asked
Assofermet's request rests on four points, as reported by SteelOrbis and the hardware trade title BricoMagazine:
- Scope explosion. The European Parliament's amendments of 15 September 2026 would bring roughly 500 additional product categories into CBAM scope — finished and semi-finished steel and aluminium goods, including hardware, springs, hinges, tools, machinery components, household articles and metal fittings for construction.
- SME exposure. These are precisely the goods imported in small volumes but wide variety by distributors and processors, who would face declarant registration, embedded-emissions data collection and certificate purchase even at very low tonnages.
- The weight-mismatch problem. For a manufactured article, total product weight diverges substantially from the weight of CBAM-covered material it contains, so a single uniform mass threshold applied equally to billet and to a box of hinges is disproportionate.
- Remedy. A new impact assessment covering downstream product characteristics, import volumes and administrative costs; differentiated thresholds by product category if warranted; plus monitoring and anti-circumvention safeguards.
Assofermet supports the ask by citing earlier Commission analysis suggesting a 500 t threshold would exempt about 97% of importers while still capturing 96.43% of embedded emissions in the sectors originally covered. That figure is second-hand — attributed to the Commission by the association, not located in a published Commission document — and it should be treated as such until the underlying analysis surfaces.
The 50-tonne figure has a specific parentage
Regulation (EU) 2025/2083 amended the CBAM Regulation (EU) 2023/956 to introduce a single, cumulative, mass-based de minimis of 50 tonnes per importer per calendar year. Parliament's own framing at the time of adoption was that this would exempt roughly 90% of importers while retaining about 99% of the CO2 emissions embedded in covered imports. The design objective, written into the file, was to keep at least 99% of emissions in scope.
The Commission then published its de minimis assessment on 30 September 2026: for the reference period 1 April 2025 to 31 March 2026, the 50 t threshold would exempt only 0.87% of embedded emissions — comfortably below the 1% statutory ceiling. In other words, the existing threshold is not running near its legal limit. There is headroom, but not much.
| Threshold | Importers exempt (reported) | Emissions covered (reported) | Emissions left out |
|---|---|---|---|
| 50 t (current law) | ~90% (EP framing) | ~99% (EP framing); 0.87% exempt per Commission assessment | ~1% or less |
| 500 t (Assofermet ask) | ~97% (Commission analysis as cited) | 96.43% | ~3.6% |
Figures as reported by the respective institutions and by Assofermet. The 3.6% column is arithmetic derived from the quoted coverage rates, not a published figure.
Read against the 1% ceiling, a 500 t threshold implies roughly triple to quadruple the permitted leakage. That is why Assofermet is not simply asking for a number change: it is asking for the ceiling itself to be re-examined for downstream goods. Its request for a fresh impact assessment is the legally coherent form of that ask.
The product-list discrepancy matters more than the threshold
The threshold is the visible issue. The product list is the one that determines whether the threshold argument works.
The Commission's original proposal — COM(2025)0989, procedure 2025/0419(COD) — would extend CBAM from 1 January 2028 to a set of downstream goods. EPRS describes that list as 180 products with high carbon-leakage risk and high steel and/or aluminium content, averaging about 79% metal content. At 79% metal content, product weight is a serviceable proxy for CBAM-material weight, and a mass-based threshold is defensible.
The Parliament's 15 September 2026 amendments, adopted by 464 votes to 50 with 159 abstentions, went considerably wider — adding fasteners, wire, springs, household articles and more — alongside scrap-content reporting, systematic ex ante country-level default values for high-risk country/good combinations, simplified reporting for least-developed-country suppliers, removal of the Article 6 credits option and rejection of the Commission's price-shock safeguard. It is that amended list, not the Commission's, that produces Assofermet's "~500 categories."
The file has been referred back to committee for interinstitutional negotiations. The Council adopted its position on strengthening CBAM on 12 June 2026. Both the product list and the threshold design are therefore live as the trilogue opens — which is what gives the letter its operational relevance, and also what narrows its likely effect. If the final list converges toward the Commission's higher-metal-content set, Assofermet's weight-mismatch argument loses much of its force for those goods; it would survive mainly for the low-metal-content household and hardware items Parliament added.
Where the weight-mismatch argument bites — and where it does not
The mismatch is real but highly product-specific. Consider representative cases (illustrative metal content, analysis):
| Product | Approx. metal share of shipped weight | Consequence of a mass-based 50 t threshold |
|---|---|---|
| Hot-rolled coil, billet, slab | ~100% | Threshold equals CBAM material almost exactly; no distortion |
| Fasteners, springs, wire | high (typically >90%) | Modest distortion; mass is a fair proxy |
| Hand tools, hinges, fittings | moderate to high | Some distortion; embedded emissions tracked reasonably |
| Machinery components, household articles | low to moderate | Material distortion; CBAM material may be a small fraction of mass |
The practical result is that a 50 t threshold on a machinery component with 20% steel content effectively imposes CBAM obligations at 10 t of covered material — well below the intended exemption level. That is the strongest technical point in Assofermet's letter, and it does not depend on the contested 97%/96.43% figures at all. A threshold defined on CBAM-material content rather than gross product mass would address it without touching the 1% ceiling. Assofermet gestures at this with its call for differentiated thresholds, but does not make it the centrepiece.
What to watch
Three things will determine the outcome, and none of them is the headline number:
- The final product list. A list near the Commission's 180 high-metal-content products largely moots the threshold debate for those goods. A list near Parliament's 500 creates a genuine proportionality problem that the Commission will have to answer.
- Whether the 99% coverage objective is redefined. If the trilogue preserves it as a hard constraint, 500 t is arithmetically out of reach and the debate collapses into product-specific carve-outs. If it is softened for downstream goods, Assofermet's number becomes negotiable.
- Whether the threshold is redefined on content rather than mass. This is the technically cleanest fix, it costs almost nothing in emissions coverage, and it would let the Commission concede the substance of Assofermet's complaint without conceding the number.
For importers and distributors of finished steel and aluminium goods, the practical planning implication is that the operative variable is not the threshold but the eventual scoping list. Companies importing high-metal-content articles should assume CBAM exposure from 2028 and build supplier emissions data now. Companies importing low-metal-content articles have a defensible case for relief — but the mechanism for that relief is more likely to be a content-based definition than a tenfold rise in the tonnage line.
References
- SteelOrbis, "Assofermet calls on EU to raise CBAM exemption threshold to 500 mt," 11 November 2026.
- BricoMagazine, "CBAM, Assofermet chiede alla Ue di rivedere la soglia."
- Regulation (EU) 2025/2083 amending the CBAM Regulation (EU) 2023/956, EUR-Lex.
- European Commission, "CBAM de minimis threshold assessment," 30 September 2026.
- European Commission, "CBAM definitive regime," DG TAXUD.
- European Parliament press release, "CBAM: Parliament adopts simplifications to the EU carbon leakage instrument," September 2025.
- European Parliament Legislative Observatory, procedure 2025/0419(COD), document summary.
- European Parliamentary Research Service, briefing on CBAM extension to downstream products.
- European Commission proposal COM(2025)0989.
- Council of the EU, "Council moves to strengthen the EU's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism," 12 June 2026.
Source & methodology +
MetalMate separates original-source evidence from summary and analysis. Verify the original source before procurement, legal or engineering decisions.
- Article status
- Published · Version 1
- Source date
- 11 November 2026
- MetalMate publication
- 11 November 2026
- Verification
- Automated evidence checks; not human reviewed
Assofermet calls on EU to raise CBAM exemption threshold to 500 mt — SteelOrbis
